What is the difference between a tin whistle and a recorder

You simply won't use the recorder's F-natural, etc. The notes above 2nd octave A are certainly more complicated on the recorder, but it's possible to become fluent with them. A bigger problem, in my opinion, is that most people, when they learn to play the recorder, are taught to tongue almost all notes.

Once learned, this is a hard habit to unlearn. It's something I struggle with on the whistle, and will probably struggle for a long time. But that's not a limitation of the recorder; it's just a limitation of many recorder players, myself included. Now that I've been playing whistle a little while, I sometimes try playing the tunes on the recorder, using whistle phrasing, and whistle ornamentation.

The result is pretty different from my usual recorder playing. Whether it's decent ITM is another question, but since my whistle playing is still in its infancy, I'm not in a position to answer it. Judging by her youtube channel, her main musical interest is harmonica, but she seems very talented in any case. Personally, I like the simplicity of the whistle, but I still like to play the recorder, and I've been having a little fun with the ocarina too.

It's all good. Post by violinmyster » Wed Oct 22, pm Thanks hoopy Mike for your link. Now I have seen it all. Why didn't I save myself tons of money and go buy a bunch of broccoli to play instead of worrying about which whistle is better to buy. Post by West » Wed Oct 22, pm I actually bought a cheap recorder a while back, just out of curiosity. It doesn't make much sense to me in terms of fingering though I suppose actually trying to learn it would help nor does it sound very good.

If I want to play square waves, I'll use an analog synth Seriously though, I have nothing against recorders. I just prefer whistles. But the whistle does strike me as a lot easier to get proficient at.

This works well for high pitch recorders compared to low pitch recorders as usually recorders have larger diameter pipe compared to tin whistles , which is not so good in creating by 2nd harmonic the second octave with the same fingering. Then use the front 6 holes as with Irish whistles and use the thumb hole not as a note hole but just to excite the 2nd harmonic and the 2nd octave by opening a little only.

Sign up to join this community. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top. Stack Overflow for Teams — Collaborate and share knowledge with a private group. Create a free Team What is Teams? Learn more. Ask Question. Asked 5 years, 2 months ago. Active 1 year, 5 months ago. Viewed 7k times. Improve this question. Angom Angom 3 3 silver badges 6 6 bronze badges.

Add a comment. Active Oldest Votes. The short answer: no, there isn't. The long answer: The six-hole chart you give for your tin whistle is for a tin whistle in D. Of course there are so many varieties that it is a bit harder to answer this any more precisely than that. You want to make sure they are easy to blow but preferably good enough not to provide the squeaks.

A whistle made in the same way would have a similar timbre, regardless of fingering system. However, that does not mean that the notes are smaller or even nearer to each other.

The whistle is suited to that kind of music because, in a sense, the music has evolved with the whistle in its midst. The tin whistle is closely associated with Celtic and Australian folk music. COM In fact, note.

The tin whistle is a diatonic instrument, meaning it can only play 7 notes, therefore they are limited to the notes of one scale. I hope to help you on your journey to find your sound! They start wars. For those of you wanting to learn a new musical instrument two good places to start are with the descant recorder and the tin whistle which is also called the penny whistle.

In general, the tin whistle has a lighter tone in comparison to the recorder. The most important difference between tin whistles and recorders to me, personally, is the sound. A recorder has a bit more of brash sound, to me which I think is captured really well in this YouTube video that I made:. Technique makes a big difference here, you will get a much different sound from player to player, but in general, the recorder has a stronger sound, while the tin whistle sounds more earthy to me.

This all depends on the design of the instrument as well. Some recorders and tin whistles may be harder to distinguish if you were only able to listen and not see the instrument.

In general, the tin whistle has a lighter tone in comparison to the recorder. Both the Tin Whistle and the Recorder share the much of the same design. The main differences in appearance is the number of fingerings holes in the flute. This particular recorder depicted has 7 holes in the front technically 10, as the last two holes are actually two small holes right next to each other , while the back has one hole. Another major difference between tin whistles and recorders are the number of notes that the instruments can play.